In the final stretch of a heated District 8 City Council race, Mayor Ron Nirenberg’s former chief of staff, Ivalis Meza Gonzalez, is attacking realtor Sakib Shaikh for unpaid taxes, while Shaikh has in turn accused Meza Gonzalez of monetizing her City Hall connections through lobbying work.

District 8 encompasses the city’s far Northwest side — some of San Antonio’s wealthiest enclaves — and six candidates are facing off in an unusually expensive race.

Longtime incumbent Councilman Manny Pelaez (D8) is running for mayor after eight years in the role, and several candidates at the San Antonio Report’s debate Thursday suggested the mudslinging was indicative of the need for fresh blood.

Read about all of the candidates running in District 8 in our 2025 Voter Guide

Shaikh wasted no time in his opening statement, saying he wanted to set the record straight after Meza Gonzalez had “chosen to run a negative campaign and tell lies about me to voters” about an Airbnb property he owned that lost its permit for failure to pay hotel occupancy taxes.

He in turn filed an ethics complaint against Meza Gonzalez alleging she’d violated the city’s lobbying policy — something Meza Gonzalez defended vehemently in Thursday’s debate, calling Shaikh’s assertions “completely fabricated.”

In another heated moment, many of the candidates harshly criticized Pelaez’s time in the District 8 office, drawing cheers from the audience at Country Village Plaza’s Elevate Events.

Rodney Kidd, who has a background in technology and logistics, and Cesario Garcia, a conservative activist and former TV journalist, both earned applause for giving Pelaez’s performance in the role a failing grade — an F and a D-minus, respectively.

Garcia even went as far as saying San Antonio needs its own Department of Government Efficiency.

“I notice that the crowd only claps when it’s a very low grade,” said Shaikh, a former District 8 constituent services director in Pelaez’s office, who gave the incumbent an A-minus.

Sakib Shaikh, left, and Cesario Garcia, right, are shown at the San Antonio Report candidate Debate for District 8 on Thursday evening. Credit: Brenda Bazán / San Antonio Report

Attorney Paula McGee, who served on the council’s Ethics Review Board, said City Council at large needs an overall conduct reboot.

“We should have better decorum,” McGee, who leads the pack in fundraising, said of the dispute between Shaikh and Meza Gonzalez. “We’ve watched this kind of stuff go on with the City Council before, and I think it’s disappointing.”

Early voting for the May 3 election runs April 22 through April 29. If no candidate takes at least 50% of the vote on May 3, the top two finishers will advance to a June 7 runoff.

On the defense

According to Shaikh, who owns several rental properties, the bad blood with Meza Gonzalez started when she unloaded a folder of opposition research on him at an editorial board meeting, and then used those attacks against him when talking to voters on the campaign trail.

Meza Gonzalez said Thursday that she doesn’t talk to voters about Shaikh when she’s knocking doors, but defended bringing his tax issues to light.

“The city of San Antonio had an active lawsuit against you for taxes you just recently paid off,” Meza Gonzalez said. “You also had a short-term rental that was revoked because you didn’t pay the [hotel occupancy] taxes back to the city. These are all important issues that I think residents need to know and they care about.”

Later in the event, Meza Gonzalez, who works as a consultant at Andrade-Van de Putte & Associates, attacked Shaikh for filing an ethics complaint alleging that she had skirted rules prohibiting former city employees from turning around and immediately lobbying their former colleagues.

Though she works at a government consulting firm, Meza Gonzalez told the Express-News she only assists the firm’s lobbyists and tracks legislation, and on Thursday she criticized Shaikh for “weaponizing an ethics complaint system” to “score political points.”

“That ethics complaint went to an independent counsel that our property taxes paid for, and it was completely fabricated,” she said. “Nothing from top to bottom occurred in that complaint.”

It was dismissed by the independent attorney the city hired to look into it,

Nevertheless, Shaikh insisted Thursday that the point he’d sought to make was still relevant to the race.

“This isn’t about this meeting or that meeting,” he said. “She engaged in lobbying activity. She works for a lobbying firm. She met with council members to lobby on behalf of a private entity. She took the knowledge associated with City Hall and used it to profit clients.”

Meza Gonzalez has the backing of Nirenberg, Bexar County Judge Peter Sakai and the police union. Shaikh has the endorsement of Council members Melissa Cabello Havrda (D6) and Jalen McKee-Rodriguez (D2).

Cindy Onyekwelu speaks at the San Antonio Report debate for District 8 on Thursday evening. Credit: Brenda Bazán / San Antonio Report

The rest of the pack

Cindy Onyekwelu, a software engineering contractor who most recently worked for the Air Force within Port San Antonio, brought an apolitical approach to the race, saying she’s attended candidate forums hosted by the local Democrats, Republicans and Libertarians.

The Houston native said she’d traveled extensively to other large cities and settled in San Antonio in part because it’s one of the safest cities she’d experienced. She called for the city to expand transit options and walkability in a district she said is unaffordable to people who work in its many service industry and retail jobs.

“A lot of people say they fear [transit] will cause more homelessness, or some type of, lower-income [influx to the district], but it wouldn’t,” Onyekwelu said. “It would just get all the lower-income workers to our lavish places to better serve our needs.”

Kidd detailed plans to make District 8 the “music capital” of San Antonio by building an amphitheater for live performances and broadcasts.

“We need something to support the new Spurs center where they practice, La Cantera [and] UTSA,” he said. “We need that so we can recruit people, bring businesses here to San Antonio, to one of our most thriving districts.”

Garcia, who is running in District 8 for the third time this year, railed against plans to allow VIA Metropolitan Transit to collect revenue off of resident’s cell phone bills.

“I now have more of a foothold of the issues I talk about,” he said of his third race in District 8. “There’s a nine-cent tax coming up for vote at the end of this election. No one else has talked about it.”

A wealthy district

McGee was among several candidates who called for ending the practice of “equity lens” budgeting, which distributes more city dollars to districts that are historically underinvested in.

City Council District 8 map

She said it was surprising that San Antonio makes it difficult for District 8 residents to see how much of the budget they’re receiving, given the amount of money the district pays into the city budget.

“If you think that you have gotten good representation for yourselves and your values at City Hall through this administration, then that’s fine,” McGee said. “That’s not what I bring to this. I bring a fresh perspective.”

Meza Gonzalez defended the equity lens, which started during the 2018 fiscal year budget cycle under Nirenberg’s tenure, saying there’s still plenty of room for council members to work together and solve big infrastructure needs in wealthier districts.

Shaikh said the reason the city faces problems dividing up its resources is because San Antonio still hasn’t grown the wealth of most of its residents, despite previous attempts to do so.

“As a city, we’ve outgrown our tax base,” he said, pointing to San Antonio’s fewer police officers per capita than Dallas. “The reason for that is, San Antonians just don’t earn enough money.”

Correction: This story has been updated to correctly list Meza Gonzalez’s endorsements.

Watch the San Antonio Report’s District 8 debate here:

Andrea Drusch is a Texas politics reporter covering local, state and federal government for the San Antonio Report. She has a journalism degree from TCU's Schieffer School and started her career in Washington,...