(From left) Ashley Smith and Blayne Tucker. Credit: Bonnie Arbittier and Scott Ball / San Antonio Report

Ahead of the November midterm elections, the Rivard Report invited invested parties to provide commentaries and share their points of view with voters. All commentaries are presented in original form with basic editing and fact-checking.

The three propositions proposed by the fire union are among the most hotly debated items on the November ballot. The proposed charter amendments are:

  • Prop A, which would make it easier for residents to put proposed ordinances and financial decisions to a public vote;
  • Prop B, which would limit future city managers’ salaries and tenure; and
  • Prop C, which would force binding arbitration between the union and the City on a new labor contract.

But how would the passage of these propositions affect citizens’ everyday lives? Blayne Tucker, a local attorney and small business owner, and Ashley Smith, San Antonio architect and LGBTQIA rights advocate, offer their opinions.

Click on the banners below to read their arguments.


For previous commentaries on the ballot propositions in this exclusive elections series, click here. 

Avatar photo

San Antonio Report Staff

This article was assembled by various members of the San Antonio Report staff.