(from left to right) Congressional District 23 Democratic candidates Judy Canales, Jay Hulings, Gina Ortiz Jones, Rick Treviño, and Angie Villescaz take part in a forum at the KLRN studios. Credit: Robin Jerstad for The Texas Tribune

There’s little daylight between the five candidates in the crowded Democratic primary to represent Texas’ 23rd Congressional District when it comes to core party issues.

All agree on the need for a clean vote on protections for undocumented immigrants who were brought to the country illegally as children. They all oppose a wall on the Texas-Mexico border and want to see comprehensive immigration reform. They’re supportive of reforming the healthcare system to provide some form of universal coverage. And they’d all like to see Congress address gun violence.

So at a Tuesday forum at the KLRN studios in downtown San Antonio – with just a week to go until Election Day – their few differences came when they tried to cast themselves as the best person to take on Republican incumbent U.S. Rep. Will Hurd (R-Helotes) in one of the country’s most competitive districts.

The forum was moderated by Patrick Svitek, political reporter for the Texas Tribune, and Beth Frerking, editor-in-chief of the Rivard Report. 

San Antonians Jay Hulings, a former federal prosecutor, and Gina Ortiz Jones, a former U.S. Air Force intelligence officer, cast themselves as the most formidable candidates to chip away at Hurd’s work as a CIA agent.

Gina Ortiz Jones, is given a microphone for the Democratic Candidate Forum for TX-23.
Gina Ortiz Jones is given a microphone for the Democratic Candidate Forum for TX-23.

“It’s not enough for the voters that you’re right on the issues. They are wanting a fight,” Jones said. “We’ve got to have someone who can neutralize Will Hurd’s perceived strength: his national security credentials … I have 14 years [of] experience in national security in and out of uniform.”

Hulings, touting his work on the border and in San Antonio, said he could “do to Will Hurd what no one else can” given his work as a federal prosecutor and his time as a lawyer for the the U.S. House Intelligence Committee.

“I have been a prosecutor on the border fighting the cartels and putting corrupt politicians from both parties in jail,” Hulings said. “He’s not going to have a national security advantage on me.”

A former Bill Clinton and Barack Obama appointee from Eagle Pass, Judy Canales attempted to position herself as the homegrown candidate who hails from the border. And she joined Angie Villescaz in touting that one of them could become the first Hispanic woman to represent Texas in Congress. Rick Treviño, a former high school teacher from San Antonio, was unapologetic in aligning himself with U.S. Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vermont) as the most progressive candidate.

There’s no clear frontrunner in the race, but Hulings and Jones have easily broken from the pack from a fundraising standpoint, with Jones heading into the election homestretch with more than a 2-to-1 cash-on-hand advantage over Hulings.

Raking in $282,000 in the first 45 days of 2018, Jones also raised more than three times what Hulings brought in over the same period and has picked up serious support from EMILY’s List, the influential national group that helps elect Democratic women who support abortion rights.

Fundraising, several of the candidates pointed out, will be key to winning back the district. Hurd is increasingly well-positioned, facing minimal opposition in his primary with a $1.2 million war chest he’s amassed since his 2016 re-election. Hurd, who first claimed the seat in 2014, has since built a national profile as a rising star for the GOP.

And after breaking with his party’s president, Donald Trump, on more than one occasion, recent Democratic- and Republican-aligned polling has put the incumbent’s popularity ahead of the president’s in the district, which went for Hillary Clinton in the 2016 presidential election.

The Democratic Candidate Forum for TX-23 is hosted at KLRN.
Democratic Primary candidate for Congressional District 23 participate in a debate at KLRN studios.

Acknowledging that TX-23 is home to a predominantly Hispanic population, the Democratic candidates mostly fell in line in criticizing Hurd for a voting record on immigration they argue is not as independent as his image suggests.

Spanning from San Antonio to El Paso and including hundreds of miles of the U.S.-Mexico border, TX-23 has long been considered one of the country’s most competitive districts. Republicans and Democrats have duked it out in general elections, but the district has not seen a competitive Democratic primary since 2012.

Campaigning in the crowded primary has left candidates working to pull support from distinct arms of the Democratic Party. Most notably, Hulings has leaned on endorsements from the Congressional Hispanic Caucus, the moderate Blue Dog Democrats, and his former law school classmates, Julián and Joaquin Castro. Jones is backed by former gubernatorial candidate Wendy Davis, veterans groups, and LGBTQIA groups.

That support led to one of the few tense exchanges during the forum, when Villescaz questioned Jones about a campaign contribution from the LGBT Victory Fund and asked her to make that support clear to voters, particularly Catholic voters, so that it wouldn’t be “revealed later” as part of a Republican attack.

Jones, who is an out lesbian, shot back that she was proud member of the LGBTQIA community.

“I proudly served my country under ‘Don’t ask, don’t tell,’” Jones said, referring to now-repealed law that barred LGBTQIA people from serving in the U.S. military if they acknowledged their sexual orientation. “I am proud of all the support I’ve received from underrepresented communities.”


Alexa Ura, The Texas Tribune

Alexa Ura covers politics and demographics for The Texas Tribune, where she started as an intern in 2013. She previously covered health care for the Trib. While earning her journalism degree at the University...