I’ve been waiting a long time to serve on a jury. It’s on my bucket list of unrealized life experiences. Tuesday is my next big chance. It’s my third summons this year. I was excused for out-of-state travel the first time, forgiven by Judge Laura Parker the second time for forgetting to show up, and now I am looking forward to what happens this week when I show up for duty at the Bexar County Courthouse.

A lot of people will do anything to avoid jury duty. I remember meeting one man who confided in me that he didn’t vote because he didn’t want his name to appear on voter rolls and lead to a jury summons. Citizens are summoned from the state’s driver’s license rolls, too, so sooner or later, that man was probably called. All these years, he’s forfeited his right to vote.

This will be the fifth time in my life I’ve been called to jury duty, and I’ve never been picked. Most people would consider that a good outcome. I disagree. I want to experience a jury trial as a participant rather than an observer, and since I’m not a lawyer or a bailiff, and have no interest in becoming a defendant, that means convincing a prosecutor and defense attorney this week that I’d make a good juror.

I’m attentive, open-minded, comfortable with complexity, get along well with others, and I believe the accused are innocent until proven guilty. That, however, may not be what the lawyers are looking for. Experience tells me they prefer people who are less familiar with the courthouse, its personalities, traditions, and quirks, and how the system really works. Journalists may know too much for their own good.

I grew up reading The Complete Sherlock Holmes, To Kill a Mockingbird, and 12 Angry Men. Later, it was Snow Falling on Cedars, The Crucible, A Time to Kill, even Kafka’s The Trial. I recently watched the four-part documentary on O.J. Simpson. I’m steeped in knowledge of what makes jurors tick. I could play a juror in a movie.

Bexar County Judge Laura Parker. Courtesy photo.
Bexar County Judge Laura Parker. Courtesy photo.

I called Judge Parker on Friday to tell her I was writing about my summons and asking for some perspective on the process. Parker was appointed to the newly-formed 386th Juvenile District Court by then-Gov. George W. Bush in 1999. She has held the office ever since then, no small accomplishment in a state where judges are elected and often swept out of office in partisan voting.

Parker also is very active in the community, as much or more than any judge I know in San Antonio. She’s on the board of Communities in Schools, the nationally-recognized dropout prevention organization, and the ChildSafe Advisory Council, which provides care and services for abused children.

It so happens that October is Parker’s month to serve her rotation as the judge who welcomes the hundreds of prospective jurors summoned to the courthouse Monday through Thursday. Some judges dislike the duty, but Parker is one of the judges willing to do more than her fair share.

There will be 400 to 500 other citizens showing up Tuesday morning with me and Judge Parker will greet us all and deliver a brief speech on civic engagement, duty, and the process. Then, as different courts send down word they are ready for a jury panel, groups randomly selected from the pool will be sent to individual courts where a prosecutor and defense lawyer will go through voir dire, the process of questioning prospective jurors for bias, conflict of interest, inside knowledge, and other factors that might make them undesirable jurors.

Once, nearly a decade ago, I made it into a panel, and then all the way down to the last 20 people in the courtroom. Alas, 12 good men and women were picked as jurors, but I was not one of them. A defense lawyer who seemed to like me through several rounds of questioning remembered he hadn’t asked me about my work. I identified myself as the editor of the Express-News, and he made a motion like a baseball umpire calling out a runner at third.

“Journalists don’t often get picked,” Judge Parker said. “You’re not alone. Lawyers don’t get picked, doctors don’t get picked. Ministers and church people often don’t get picked. Therapists don’t get picked. People who are known around the courthouse don’t get picked. People who are well-known to the public don’t get picked.”

The skeptic in me thinks that educated individuals who are comfortable thinking independently and gauging their level of confidence in a legal presentation by the state or the defense seldom get picked. Lawyers want jurors who will defer to their experience and judgment and will believe what they are told. Each side gets so many strikes, and sooner or later, it comes down to 12 people.

“Sometimes there are so many people who are strongly opinionated about an issue that you have to cut them all and the jury ends up being those still left,” Parker said. “People who complain about missing work are often excused, too, because no one wants to try a case in front of a juror belly aching about his lost time at work.”

I live less than one mile from the courthouse. It’s a five-minute bike ride. I’ll be there by 8 a.m., get a good seat, listen to Judge Parker’s welcome and speech, and then watch members of the pool try to lobby their way back home.

“People will come up and tell me about weird medical conditions, show me their scars, or their bag of prescription medicines,” Parker said. “If you want a medical excuse you should bring a doctor’s note.”

Some judges arrive for jury pool duty with their bailiff as a precaution. Parker’s court is at the Juvenile Detention Center at 600 Mission Rd., miles away from the courthouse, so she doesn’t have that luxury. I asked her if she has any security concerns in this day and age.

“Yes, we are careful. We just had an incident. I gave my speech and just as I finished, a man raised his hand and started yelling and went off on a crazy tirade that Hillary Clinton ought to be in prison. He was irate, so we excused him. It wasn’t worth it.”

Judge Parker told me that I’ll know by mid-afternoon if my fortunes are about to change.

“If you haven’t been sent to a court by 3 p.m. you’ll probably be sent home and be given credit and not be called for another three years,” she said.

I’ve already selected the book I’m going to read while we watch the hours go by on the courthouse clocks. It’s The Last Juror, a thriller by John Grisham. A crusading small-town newspaper editor helps assure a powerful political family is held accountable for a brutal rape and murder. The jury convicts, but a decade later, the paroled killer is released and suddenly jurors start turning up dead.

Just the kind of read to get me in the right mood to serve.

https://rivardreport.wildapricot.org

Top image: The historic Bexar County Courthouse.  Photo by Scott Ball. 

Related Stories:

An Open Letter to District Attorney Nico LaHood

Kevin Wolff to Face the Courthouse Press on Wednesday

Border Refugees Seek Justice on Dolorosa Street

Celebrating Love and Marriage in San Antonio

Robert Rivard, co-founder of the San Antonio Report who retired in 2022, has been a working journalist for 46 years. He is the host of the bigcitysmalltown podcast.

8 replies on “Pick Me: A Journalist Reports for Jury Duty”

  1. Like you, serving on a jury was on my bucket list. When I was finally selected in my mid 60’s, I had expected that I would need to take a lead role among our 12 in holding to the law and finding the truth. I had thought I would be somewhat alone among a group who were more interested in getting home or in simply seeking a pound of flesh. How arrogant of me! My fellow jurors were dutiful and conscientious and truly focused on attaining justice in the case. The brief episode affirmed my pride in our nation and our system of law and my deep gratitude for my American citizenship. I hope you get to have a similar uplifting experience!

  2. I agree with you about wanting to serve. When I was impaneled in June, I was inspired by the gravity and beauty of the process, and even wrote Judge Hilbig a letter to thank him for his serious but non-intimidating manner (gauged, I think, to reach those who wanted to get outta there.) I agree with you that those with higher education and critical thinking skills are likely to be struck. However, I would differ with you on getting there bright and early. I was the last to arrive and first to be impaneled! Being #1 made me optimistic about being picked, but alas, ’twas not to be. Good luck!

  3. Being selected has always been my desire also. I have made it on the selection panel but have always been eliminated after questioning. My Dad was a Navy Medic, my Aunt an Air Force Nurse, those facts have gotten me eliminated twice. I hope you are selected, I can’t wait to hear the story you will tell.

  4. Me too, as above. Retiring and being a woman seemed to help. Just this past year I was selected after years of being dismissed even though I was empanelled twice.
    Serving made me feel a part of an important process. Our case involved having an interpreter. It lasted about three days. The jurors were all attentive. They came from varied backgrounds and education levels. We were ethnically mixed and fairly evenly divided by gender and race.
    The judge was fair and was clearly in charge and paying attention.
    Yes, there were boring times. Yes, I had to concentrate. Yes, we were allowed to ask the judge for help in clarification. Most of all, the jurors were serious about trying to get it right. We talked it through and voted.
    The outcome doesn’t matter here but it really mattered to the people at the center of the case.
    Together we made a decision. It’s the together part that is important. No one person decided but we used the information provided in the trial to make a decision, together.
    I wish that the rest of our democracy worked this well.
    Good luck Mr. Rivard. Hope you get to serve your community in this way.

  5. If you want to get picked for Jury Duty, don’t ask questions. If you answer wrong, one of the lawyers will recuse you. If you answer right, the other lawyer will recuse you. Here are things lawyers look for when picking a jury: http://mentalfloss.com/article/62514/9-things-lawyers-look-when-picking-jury  
    I think you would be a great juror. In fact, I think you would make a great foreman. Here are 10 characteristics of a jury foreman: http://www.a2lc.com/blog/bid/65718/10-Ways-to-Spot-Your-Jury-Foreman  

  6. I’ve been called in 5 times in to jury duty in the 23 years I’ve lived in Bexar County. I’ve served on 3 juries. One attorney noted during voir dire, if you don’t ask questions or speak up much, you’re more likely to be selected.

  7. The writer is probably right about those who are thinkers and readers not usually being selected–that lawyers only want people who will believe what lawyers and their witnesses say in trials say to be the truth. The last time I was sent to a courtroom for panel interviews as a part of the jury selection process, the lawyer for the accused stated that it is just as likely that a girl would commit as it is that a boy would. He went to a lot of trouble trying emphasize that this only made sense due to the fact that there are just as many girls as boys in general within the population. I was about number 30 in the list of prospective jurors he was questioning. He got the first 29 to agree with him. I didn’t. He asked why. I said because statistics show that far more males commit crimes than females. He asked, “And you believe in statistics?” I replied, “Yes, I’m a mathematician.” I got cut from jury duty. While waiting outside before the final selections, a woman approached me and said, “I couldn’t believe everyone was agreeing with what the lawyer was asking. I’m glad you spoke up.”

  8. I am a well-educated woman who can walk to the Courthouse and has time to serve on a jury. I’ve held a Texas drivers license for 50 years and been registered to vote in Bexar County for 45 years. I’ve only been called for jury duty at County court three times and never been interviewed. But perhaps like Mary Grace Ketner, now that I’m in my mid-60s, my time will come. On the other hand, my husband who at the time was a registered professional engineer and lawyer, was picked to serve on a week-long construction liability case. Go figure………..

Comments are closed.